Holidays

Cheese Balls

Cheese Balls

Are you looking for  just the right thing to bring to a holiday party or to serve as an appetizer to family and friends during the holidays? Keyes Creamery cheese balls are the answer. We shred our flavorful cheese and combine it with the finest ingredients to create, well as one of our customers puts it, “heaven on a cracker.” You can buy the cheese balls individually or combine them into a gift box. Choose from Old Bay made with our Colby Longhorn, Buttermilk Ranch, or Cranberry Cheddar both made with our Aged Cheddar.

The cheese balls are offered in two sizes to accommodate any holiday celebration. The large balls weigh one pound ($11.00) and the small are half-a-pound ($9.00). They can also be frozen to be eaten at a later time.

Cheese Gift Boxes

Keyes Creamery cheese makes an amazing, tasty gift for the holiday season. We sell gift boxes with your choice of three or four 10 oz. blocks of assorted cheeses or with two or three cheese blocks and a cheese ball too! We place the cheese in specially packed gift boxes and can even ship them*! Call the store or stop in for prices and to place you order.

*We do not ship the cheese balls and please call us to verify shipping prices

Seasonal Ice Cream Flavors

Every year we offer multiple holiday flavors that you can find through out the fall and into December. Some of these flavors are offered not only in quarts and pints but also in our retail store to be dipped in to cups, cones, milkshakes and more! For the 2023 holiday season you can find the following flavors on the dates listed below through our store and through several other store fronts that offer our ice cream.”

  • Cinnamon Apple Pie- September 24th
  • Pumpkin Roll- October 7th
Keyes Creamery Building
Keyes Creamery Building

Ice Cream Pies

Ice cream pies make a great and different dessert for your holiday celebration or party! They are offered in either a Graham Cracker Crust or an Oreo Crust. Several flavor combinations are offered for both Thanksgiving and Christmas! Call to place your order today!

Thanksgiving

  • Black Raspberry and Vanilla ice cream in a Graham Cracker Crust
  • Pumpkin and Vanilla ice cream in a Graham Cracker Crust
  • Cows Feet and Chocolate ice cream in a Oreo Crust
  • Peppermint Chip and Chocolate ice cream in a Oreo Crust
  • Pumpkin and Graham Cracker ice cream in a Graham Cracker Crust

Christmas

  • Black Raspberry and Vanilla ice cream in a Graham Cracker Crust
  • Pumpkin and Vanilla ice cream in a Graham Cracker Crust
  • Cows Feet and Chocolate ice cream in a Oreo Crust
  • Peppermint Chip and Chocolate ice cream in a Oreo Crust
  • Bergermintster Mintsterberger and Chocolate ice cream in a Oreo Crust

Wedding Sundae Bars

Looking for something different to add to your wedding dessert menu? How about a sundae bar?! Keyes Creamery is now offering sundae bars for weddings! A tasting date is scheduled one month prior to your wedding where you get to taste and choose which flavors and toppings you would like to have! For more questions please contact Megan at the creamery. 443-619-4975

Keyes Creamery Building