Ice Cream

Only Keyes Creamery, high-quality milk is used to make our delicious, premium ice cream. Our cows are milked twice a day to provide the purest milk available. Small batches of milk from the dairy are first pasteurized and then are made into ice cream mix. Although David Keyes would argue that the fun starts at 3:30 a.m. when he’s up to do the first of the day’s milking, the rest of us think the fun starts when the ice cream begins its transformation from the plain mix to its destiny of one of our amazing flavors. Hand-mixing every flavor right here at our new creamery means we can custom-process batches of ice cream several times a week so you are getting the freshest ice cream possible. Our flavors change occasionally, and some come and go with the seasons.

Premium Ice Cream Flavors*

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Butter Pecan
  • Cookies & Cream
  • Chocolate Chip
  • Chocolate Coconut Almond
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter
  • Strawberry
  • Black Cherry Chip
  • Black Raspberry
  • Cherry Vanilla
  • Cow’s Feet
    (chocolate chip with peanut butter swirl)
  • Goose Feathers
    (cake batter with fudge ripple)
  • Peppermint Chip
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
  • Cappuccino Crunch
  • Buttery Salted Caramel
  • Sugar-Free Fudge Ripple

See It Now- Gone Later!

(Available in the Summer only for hand dipped)
  • Honey
  • Banana
  • Banana Pecan Chip
  • Strawberry Cheesecake
  • Black Raspberry Chip
  • Red Velvet
  • Sweet Cream
  • Cotton Candy
  • Bubble Gum
  • Lemon
  • Lemon Blueberry
  • Blueberries and Cream
  • Salted Caramel Brownie

Seasonal Flavors**

  • Bergermintster Mintsterberger
  • Rum Raisin
  • Maple Walnut
  • Peach
  • Pumpkin
  • Cinnamon Apple Pie

*Sorry, but we are unable to ship ice cream at this time due to the extreme temperatures needed to keep it fresh.

**Please call for our current seasonal flavors.

Ice Cream Cakes and Ice Cream Pies

Here at Keyes Creamery, we think there are two types of people in this world: pie people and cake people. Pie people are traditional, purists, sophisticated. They enjoy our thick, two-layer ice cream pies with their choice of a graham crust (original is best) or Oreo cookie crust (when they feel a little crazy). No frosting, no toppings, and why would you? Let the ice cream speak for itself. But those cake people! They are a different breed. Off their rocker may be too strong a term, but they think eating amazing Keyes Creamery two-layer cakes while sitting in their rockers, heck, straight off of the pretty gold tray we present it on sounds like a perfect night. Two layers of delicious ice cream, any flavor you want? Yep. Thick frosting spilling off the sides? Uh-huh. Crazy toppings, as many as you can come up with? We will even throw in a cherry on top!

Pie person or cake person, we love you either way, because it’s all made from our pure milk right here at the creamery. Give us a call two weeks’ in advance and we will have your special ice cream cake or ice cream pie ready for the next celebration in your life.

Keyes Creamery on Facebook