The Keyes Creamery location opened in 2013, switching from selling at the dairy farm to having a beautiful store front. The creamery offers hand-dipped ice cream in cups, cones, and milkshakes along with many other items to choose from. While the creamery is open year-round, more flavors are offered during the months of April through October. During the holidays, several seasonal ice cream flavors are offered as well as cheese balls, ice cream pies, and cheese git boxes. During the winter all basic flavors are offered in quarts and pints and there is a pared-down, rotating menu of 6-8 flavors available for hand-dipped.
One of the many offerings you can find are ice cream cakes. The cakes are made year-round and are available through our retail store. They are made with Vanilla and Chocolate ice creams with crushed Oreos in the center. You can also place an order for a cake through our store or on the Order Request page. Choose from our basic ice cream flavors and toppings to create your custom cake. Make sure to give 2 weeks for the order to be processed.
During the ice cream season we also hold a spring and a fall craft fair, Food Truck Thursdays, a celebration for National Ice Cream Day, and a different special each weekend. Some of the specials include Banana Splits, freak shakes, and Brownie Sundaes. There are also an additional 8 to 10 flavors that are available and change intermittently throughout the summer.
We also offer several other items through the store:
- Honey from Top of the Hill Apiary
- Ground Beef from Stafford Angus
- Butter from Breezy Valley Farms
- Cider from Lohr’s Orchard in the Fall
- Keyes Creamery t-shirts
