Extra Offerings

Wedding Sundae Bars

Looking for something different to add to your wedding dessert menu? How about a sundae bar?! Keyes Creamery is now offering sundae bars for weddings! A tasting date is scheduled one month prior to your wedding where you get to taste and choose which flavors and toppings you would like to have! For more questions, please contact the creamery at 443-619-4975

Holiday Cheese Balls

We shred either our Colby Longhorn, Aged Cheddar, or plain Cheddar cheese, mix it with premium ingredients, roll it in a ball, and you have yourself a delicious holiday appetizer. They also make a great hostess gift! Serve them with pretzels or crackers or even veggies. They are a crowd pleaser! The cheese balls are available in November and December for the holidays. All orders must be placed in-store or over the phone and must be paid for in advance. Available flavors are Buttermilk Ranch, Cranberry Cheddar, and Old Bay.

Ice Cream Pies

Ice cream pies make a great and different dessert for your holiday celebration or party! They are offered in either a Graham Cracker Crust or a Chocolate Crust. Several flavor combinations are offered for both Thanksgiving and Christmas! All holiday orders must be placed in-store or over the phone and must be paid for in advance.

Thanksgiving

Black Raspberry and Vanilla ice cream in a Graham Cracker Crust
Pumpkin and Vanilla ice cream in a Graham Cracker Crust
Cows Feet and Chocolate ice cream in a Chocolate Crust
Peppermint Chip and Chocolate ice cream in a Chocolate Crust

Christmas

Black Raspberry and Vanilla ice cream in a Graham Cracker Crust
Cows Feet and Chocolate ice cream in a Chocolate Crust
Peppermint Chip and Chocolate ice cream in a Chocolate Crust
Bergermintster Mintsterberger and Chocolate ice cream in a Chocolate Crust

Cheese Gift Boxes

Keyes Creamery cheese makes an amazing, tasty gift for the holiday season. We sell gift boxes with your choice of three or four 10 oz. blocks of assorted cheeses or with two or three cheese blocks and a cheese ball too! We place the cheese in specially packed gift boxes and can even ship them*! Call the store or stop in for prices and to place your order.

*We do not ship the cheese balls and please call us to verify shipping prices

Holiday Season Ice Cream Flavors

Every year we offer multiple holiday flavors that you can find throughout the fall and into December. Some of these flavors are offered not only in quarts and pints but also in our retail store to be dipped in to cups, cones, milkshakes and more! You can find them not only through our store but through several of our wholesale store fronts that offer our ice cream. Some of the flavors we have offered in the past are:

Cinnamon Apple Pie
Caramel Apple
Pumpkin Caramel Pecan
Peppermint Twist
Bergermintster Mintsterberger